Holmes and Williams share hug at Dawson's Creek Broadway reunion, ending feud speculation

Broadway audiences witnessed a moment of reconciliation as Katie Holmes and Michelle Williams shared a hug during the Dawson's Creek Broadway reunion reading at the Richard Rodgers Theatre in New York City on Monday evening. The on-stage moment at curtain call appeared to resolve years of fan speculation about a rift between the former co-stars.

Holmes, who played Joey Potter opposite Williams' Jen Lindley, was seen walking onto the stage with Williams and wrapping an arm around her. The actresses linked hands during the curtain call, a gesture that social media quickly highlighted as a sign of warmth between longtime friends. The episode ends a narrative that has fueled fan chatter about a feud for more than two decades, though neither woman has publicly confirmed a rift. Holmes has repeatedly said she is on good terms with Williams and has maintained occasional contact with Williams, as well as with fellow cast member James Van Der Beek and Joshua Jackson. In past interviews, Holmes has indicated the bond among the core group endures despite busy lives.

Earlier in the program, flashback photos and videos highlighted the early years of the show before the cast — including Holmes, Williams, and Joshua Jackson — came out on stage. Busy Philipps was also part of the evening, while Van Der Beek appeared via video to say he could not attend due to cancer, with Lin-Manuel Miranda standing in for him during the reading.

Dawson's Creek aired on The WB from 1998 to 2003, later moving to The CW. The Broadway reading at the Richard Rodgers Theatre offered a nostalgic look back at the show, with cast members reflecting on its impact. The night also underscored how the series remains a touchstone for fans decades later, and how its actors have pursued varied paths since the show ended.

Holmes has remained connected with the Dawson cast in recent projects, including a film with Jackson, underscoring their continuing friendship. Holmes recently filmed a new movie with Jackson, illustrating that the collaboration and camaraderie among the group persists even after nearly 30 years.

Overall, the reunion highlighted the enduring cultural footprint of Dawson's Creek and the capacity of its original cast to draw fans back for a live event. The moment between Holmes and Williams will likely be seen as a significant milestone for fans who followed the show through its original run and beyond.