Kimmel's comeback hinges on apology as affiliates balk at return

Jimmy Kimmel Live! is set to return to ABC platforms Tuesday after being pulled last week over controversial remarks about Charlie Kirk’s assassination. Disney, the show's parent company, said the program would resume following thoughtful conversations with Kimmel. But Sinclair and Nexstar, which together control about a third of ABC’s local affiliates, have said they will not broadcast the episode on their stations, presenting a split rollout in key markets.

Industry insiders say those affiliates want to see a sincere apology from Kimmel and to hear plans for a less divisive program if the show is to win back conservative viewers. They note that affiliates are reluctant to commit without clear messaging, and the decision to withhold airings reflects concerns about audience and ad revenue in local markets. The stalemate highlights how local stations weigh network content against the political and cultural dynamics that shape their audiences.

The dispute underscores broader shifts in late-night television as right-leaning audiences push back against what some see as one-sided panels and bias on programs perceived as part of liberal-leaning media. In markets where conservative sentiment is stronger, observers say reactions to Kimmel’s remarks and the surrounding controversy have been particularly pronounced, influencing decisions at the local affiliate level in places such as the western and mountain regions.

Disney and ABC executives have been coordinating with Turning Point USA representatives to resolve the impasse, with Disney leadership reportedly seeking a peaceful pathway forward. People familiar with the talks describe a desire for accountability and a clear signal that the show will be less divisive if it returns to the airwaves. While ABC has not released transcripts of tonight’s planned monologue, insiders say the content of Tuesday’s show could determine how many affiliates ultimately broadcast the program.

Ultimately, Tuesday’s airing may hinge on Kimmel’s approach. If he delivers a sincere apology and outlines steps to balance the program’s voice, some affiliates may reconsider their decision to withhold. If not, the show’s return could be delayed further in markets where local stations gauge the risk to their audiences and advertisers. Disney officials have signaled a preference for resolving the dispute quickly, aiming to restore a measure of civility to a highly charged moment in the culture-and-entertainment landscape.