Arch Manning throws four TDs in Texas' 38-7 win, but fans remain unconvinced
Sophomore quarterback bounces back against San Jose State, but critics point to an 83-yard score and last week's loss to Ohio State
Arch Manning completed 19 of 30 passes for 295 yards and four touchdowns and helped No. 7 Texas beat San Jose State 38-7 on Saturday in Austin, but some fans and observers remained skeptical of the sophomore's progress after his uneven start to the season.
Manning also threw one interception and added a rushing touchdown. His longest scoring play, an 83-yard touchdown to Parker Livingstone, drew particular scrutiny: replays showed a San Jose State defensive back slipping after what initially appeared to be a 20-yard completion, and some analysts and viewers said the throw was underthrown and the defender's misstep turned it into a long run.
The performance represented a clear statistical rebound from Texas' season opener, when the Longhorns struggled in a loss at Ohio State. That Week 1 outing left supporters questioning Manning's readiness under center and intensified scrutiny of the program's decision to install the third-generation Manning as its franchise quarterback.
Against San Jose State, the Longhorns' offense moved the ball consistently and converted opportunities into points, producing four passing touchdowns and a dominant margin on the scoreboard. Texas' defense limited the Spartans to seven points and helped preserve the one-sided result late in the game.
Despite the comfortable final score, critics focused on the quality of some completions and on situational decision-making. Social media posts and fan commentary emphasized that the 83-yard score owed at least part of its length to a defensive miscue, rather than being a pure showcase of arm strength or placement. The interception also drew attention as evidence that the sophomore still faces challenges against more disciplined opponents.
Manning's status as a high-profile recruit and member of the Manning family has heightened expectations and the intensity of public reaction. Texas coaches have defended the sophomore's progress, citing film study and practice reps, while noting room for improvement in timing and situational accuracy.
Saturday's victory provided the Longhorns with a bounce-back result in their nonconference slate, but it did little to settle the debate about Manning's trajectory. Fans and analysts said his complete body of work — including the Week 1 loss in Columbus and this weekend's mixed elements — will remain a focal point as Texas moves deeper into its season and faces stiffer competition.