Petgrave signs with Indy Fuel, returning to ice two years after Adam Johnson tragedy

Matt Petgrave, the Canadian defenseman involved in the on-ice incident that led to Adam Johnson’s death, has signed with the Indy Fuel, the ECHL affiliate of the Chicago Blackhawks, for this season. The 33-year-old signed a standard player contract, marking his return to competitive hockey nearly two years after the Oct. 28, 2023, collision in the United Kingdom that left Johnson fatally injured.

Petgrave’s signing was announced by the Fuel on Tuesday. The team noted that there were no criminal charges following the incident. "We are aware that Matt was involved in a tragic accident two years ago on the ice, where another player lost his life," Fuel CEO Sean Hallett said in a statement. "No criminal charges were brought against Matt after the accident. After in-depth discussions with him and his previous coaches and teammates, we believe he should be afforded the opportunity to continue his playing career. Matt Petgrave is signing with an ECHL team." The Fuel added that Petgrave had signed a contract for the upcoming season.

Petgrave also issued a statement through the Fuel expressing gratitude for the second chance: "I am thankful to the Fuel organization and the city of Indianapolis for allowing me the opportunity to continue my professional career in the sport I love." He is returning to North American professional hockey after spending time overseas.

Before returning to North American hockey, Petgrave spent two seasons with Sheffield in the United Kingdom’s Elite Ice Hockey League, where he tallied 51 points in 61 games. His career in North American professional hockey prior to heading overseas included stints within the Vancouver Canucks organization, including time in the AHL and ECHL.

The incident that brought Petgrave to international attention occurred during a game between the Sheffield Steelers and the Nottingham Panthers. A collision led to Johnson’s skate blade slicing the neck of the Nottingham player, resulting in Johnson’s death. Johnson’s passing prompted a police investigation; South Yorkshire Police arrested Petgrave two weeks after the incident on suspicion of manslaughter before releasing him on bail while the inquiry continued. In-April, the Crown Prosecution Service announced that it would not bring criminal charges against Petgrave.

The Indy Fuel and the Chicago Blackhawks organization emphasized that the move reflects an opportunity for Petgrave to resume his professional career and contribute to the team. Fuel officials said they were committed to supporting him and his transition back onto the ice, while acknowledging the sensitive and high-profile nature of the case.

The signing adds to a narrative that intersects professional hockey, legal processes, and the ongoing conversations about accountability and opportunities for players who have faced harsh scrutiny in the aftermath of on-ice tragedies. By welcoming Petgrave back to competition, the Fuel are signaling a path for players dealing with extraordinary circumstances to continue pursuing their careers within the bounds of league rules and legal outcomes.

As Petgrave begins training with the Fuel, the organization will be monitoring his integration into the roster and the broader team dynamic. Indianapolis, home to a storied hockey culture, is preparing for a season that includes a mix of veteran leadership and rising talent, with Petgrave expected to contribute on defense and provide depth to the lineup. The team’s management has stressed that this is a process that will prioritize both performance and the well-being of everyone involved, including teammates, staff, and the community that supports them.

This season marks a continued tie between the Blackhawks and their ECHL affiliate, a relationship designed to develop players and provide opportunities for those looking to climb the professional ladder. Petgrave’s return to North American hockey through the Indy Fuel is one of several narratives shaping the league’s 2025-26 season, underscoring how teams balance competitive aims with complex personal and legal histories.