Britons’ Spanish dream, tax shocks and cultural frictions: three expats share their relocations

Britons who moved to Spain in search of a sunnier, easier life describe a reality that often diverged sharply from the dream: surprise taxes, anti-British attitudes, and personal upheaval that in some cases ended in debt or divorce.

In 2001, Mandy Green and her husband left their jobs in Fife for Majorca, drawn by the island’s climate and pace of life. They bought a beachside restaurant in Santa Ponsa and set about turning a hospitality dream into a family business. What followed was a cascade of unexpected costs and logistical headaches. Mandy recalls that their first months were punctuated by a constant stream of invoices they hadn’t anticipated. “We’d get hit with out-of-the-blue tax bills,” she says. “We’d been in our restaurant for a month when our accountant presented us with a tax bill for €300 (£260). It totally took us by surprise as we had no idea what it was for and it wasn’t something we’d been told to budget for.”

The couple’s income fluctuated with tourist seasons, while costs—especially food supplies and utilities—became unpredictable. Mandy notes that even as the restaurant appeared successful to visitors, tax bills and price swings eroded profits. “While the restaurant did well, our customers were mainly holidaying Brits. There were so many things we didn’t expect. Food supply prices went up and down all the time. There were constant tax surprises.” They eventually sold the business in 2016, after years of exhausting hours and mounting strain on their marriage. Mandy describes feeling exhausted, working opposite shifts with her husband, and watching their family life fray. Their daughter moved back to Scotland after seven years on the island, and their son left for Ireland. The couple divorced ten months after selling the restaurant, and Mark began a new life with a local partner. Mandy, now 61, returned to Scotland six years ago and lives alone while continuing to care for her two children from afar.

[image: ]

Another couple who tried their luck with Spain’s hospitality scene found a different set of hurdles. In 2019 a Shropshire-based family bought a themed English pub in Murcia and a rural finca, drawn by the idea of a relaxed pace and warm climate. The husband, who had two decades of experience in running pubs, and his wife, who spoke some Spanish thanks to a prior stint in Majorca, expected a smooth transition. Instead they encountered entrenched local attitudes that soured their experience. The wife says the local population could be hostile toward British newcomers: “In Murcia they were very racist towards the English. Places like Marbella embrace expats, but the small fishing village where we were based just didn’t welcome change. Every time I tried to do something it was ‘no comprendo’.” Even when they did manage to communicate, bureaucratic friction persisted. She recalls being hit by higher-than-expected taxes, while the administration sometimes failed to recognize payments, threatening vehicles with embargoes rather than acknowledging proof of payment.

The couple also faced daily life challenges beyond taxes and language. They found it difficult to connect with neighbors or find reliable services, and their experience with local schools for their child highlighted another reality for expat families: access to adequate childcare and education can be limited. After a year of growing frustration, they decided to return to the United Kingdom. They still own the bar and the finca, but rent them out as they reorient their lives toward the UK.

The third account comes from a retiree who moved to Nerja in Andalusia seeking relief from gray winters in Dorset. The plan was simple: start anew while keeping a foothold in the UK. The couple bought a one-way ticket to Malaga, but their experience quickly soured. The apartment they rented proved expensive and ill-suited to long-term living: “We paid almost €1,500 (£1,310) a month for a crushingly ordinary apartment in Nerja. The air-con units leaked and the walls were thin.” They also faced ongoing maintenance issues in a country where seasonal life can complicate service and repairs, and their social circle never quite filled the gap they anticipated. The pool—a communal feature of their development—became a source of tension as local residents and visitors used it, limiting the couple’s sense of privacy and security.

The nightmares of living abroad extended beyond everyday inconveniences. The retiree describes persistent anxiety that culminated in a sudden decision to return to Scotland after nine months. “From the moment we arrived in the autumn, things started to go wrong,” she recalls. “I’d been having nightmares: I was locked in our apartment and couldn’t get out. I cried with relief when my husband suggested we go home.” Back in Scotland, she cared for a mother facing dementia while rebuilding a life abroad-centered around family and stability rather than a foreign address.

Across these cases, several common threads emerge. Officials and guides frequently emphasize Spain’s appeal for British settlers: milder winters, lower overall living costs, and a robust expat network. Official Spanish government statistics show 275,000 UK nationals living legally in Spain last year, while The Local estimates that the true number is higher, potentially surpassing 400,000. Yet the experiences described by Mandy, the Murcia family, and the Nerja couple illustrate a different reality: the climate may be sunny, but the financial and social climate can be unpredictable and unforgiving.

Mandy, who returned to Scotland in 2019, remains candid about the decision to relocate: the dream of a sun-kissed life never fully translated into a simple, stable daily routine. “Did we do the right thing in moving to Spain? I do wonder. My daughter never settled and I’m divorced,” she says. She continues to support her family from afar while reflecting on the lessons she learned: do thorough due diligence, avoid assuming that a well-placed account and reputable agents will shield you from day-to-day realities, and prepare for ongoing costs that can stretch a business thin.

For others considering a move, these accounts offer a stark reminder that popular narratives about expat life—sun, sea, and cheap living—often overlook the structural and cultural frictions that can derail even the best-laid plans. A six-month on-the-ground trial, language immersion, and a conservatively funded financial plan may help mitigate some of the most acute risks, but no amount of preparation fully guarantees an effortless transition.

Ultimately, the stories underscore a broader truth: Spain may remain a magnet for Britons seeking a new start, but the path is not without peril. As one participant cautions, the overseas dream requires not only a sunny climate but a readiness to navigate tax regimes, bureaucracy, and local attitudes—factors that can dramatically shape whether the dream endures or dissolves into a more complicated reality.